IPA Takeover Amalgamate IFA – Pt2

IPA takeover amalgamate IFA 2014IPA Takeover Amalgamate IFA – Pt2

In this shorter post, simply entitled IPA Takeover Amalgamate IFA – Pt2, I just wanted to share a few further thoughts and concerns that I have. I am also devising a comprehensive set of questions that I would urge EVERY member to ask of the management team BEFORE voting commences in December.

Dangling Carrots

For this acquisition (or takeover) by the Institute Public Accountants (IPA) of Australia of the Institute of Financial Accountants (IFA), a vote of more than 50% agreeing to the takeover needs to ratified by the members of the IFA. In every effort to secure this vote, the management team at Burford House are making best use of their position and are dangling carrots in order to entice a YES vote. For instance:-

Application to Privy Council for Chartered Status of the Institute

This is perhaps the biggest carrot being dangled and will, in all probability, go no where. A simple check of the Privy Council web site will tell you this. Have a look here at the Applying for a Royal Charter page. It is my belief that the IFA will NOT be given the Charter as they do not fulfil the criteria – they fail massively on point c! Also bear in mind the cost, potentially around £250,000, just for the application process and NO guarantee of success. I also believe that this application to Privy Council for Chartered Status of the Institute is the ONLY reason why the IPA want to acquire the IFA.

Independent Examinations of Charity Accounts

Our members are perfectly qualified and experienced to conduct this service yet why is the name of the IFA not mentioned in Charities Act 2011 as an approved body? See for yourself here on the Legislation web site. This came into force in 2011 so why was the IFA management team NOT involved in the consultation of this Act and why did they not get the Institute listed? This should be a GIVEN for the members, not a carrot whereby your YES vote means they will then look into allowing us to do independent examinations of charity accounts.

Reciprocal Membership of the IPA

Out of 9,000 members, how many of those would need a membership of an Austrailian body in order to practice? None – unless they planned on emigrating and setting up “down under”.

Is The Takeover Already A Done Deal?

I seriously had to ask myself is the takeover already a done deal? Simply because, just doing a little Google search on the proposal, I came across an article on the MoneyManagement web site in Australia which was entitled IPA and IFA Merge – this indicates that the deal has already been done and are the IFA simply going through “a process” secure in the knowledge that the vote will be ratified by the members?

You can view my official response to the proposal here.

4 thoughts on “IPA Takeover Amalgamate IFA – Pt2

  1. Barney W

    I think you may be too pessimistic about the whole thing here. Without this merger or takeover ( whatever you call it when 2 bodies consolidate) , we can hardly see any breakthrough the IFA can make in the near future. Yes, the IFA is progressing well in the last few years, but the pace is not fast enough. The whole accounting industry is changing… CA Canada, CMA and CGA are merging. Even CA Aust and CA New Zealand are also merging, so why can’t IFA and IPA follow the trend. I can see the brighter side of things of this merger for sharing knowledge, reducing costs and leveraging expertise in SME/SMP. This is indeed a golden opportunity for both institutes.

    BW

    Reply
  2. Barney W

    Once the merger is effected, I “think” the next step is to invite the Association of International Accountants or the Institute of Professional Accountants to come to the negotiation table too.

    BW

    Reply
  3. Braveheart

    It is a viable and brilliant strategy. There is no room for pessimism. Chartered Status can be achieved. It is not The Rocket Science Council. It is Privy Council made up of people. I rest my case.

    Reply
  4. davida Post author

    @Barney W.
    Merger and takeover are 2 different words with 2 different meanings so well worth defining which to use. The IPA will own the IFA 100%, it will NOT be a member organisation and the control will be with the Australians – this is not why I joined the IFA. There are also better partner available within Europe that the same thing could be achieved with but of course it means that certain people do not get their 4 holidays all expenses paid to Australia every year.

    @Braveheart
    The Privy Council has already decreed that no other organisation will receive charter status UNLESS it can prove a uniqueness. What the IFA/IPA are claiming is “aimed at the SME” – well every other accountancy body provides services to the SME so this is not unique. Also, there is other criteria where they also fail miserably. There is also the cost of approx £250k with no guarantee of success so I very much doubt whether they will achieve chartered status and certainly not in the short term.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *